Fundraiser's Friday: The Truth About Donor Board Seats!

The Nonprofit Show

Fundraising is as much an art as it is a science, requiring an understanding of donor psychology, strategic engagement, and institutional needs. In this episode of Fundraisers Friday, our cohosts dig into the nuanced realities of donor relations, tackling pressing questions about board membership, fundraising portfolios, donor engagement, and wealth screening tools.

The lively conversation begins with an ethical debate: Should major donors automatically be granted board seats? Co-host Tony Beall’s response is resolute—financial contributions should not be a ticket to governance. Instead, board membership should be earned through demonstrated commitment, expertise, and alignment with an organization’s strategic vision. He and co-host Julia Patrick explore alternative ways to recognize and honor significant donors, reinforcing the idea that influence should be wielded responsibly and not purchased outright.

Transitioning to other aspects of donor engagement, the hosts examine a frequently asked question: How many donors should a fundraiser manage in their portfolio? Tony breaks it down with precision—"major gift officers typically handle 75-150 donors, mid-level fundraisers manage 200-400, and annual fund managers may oversee up to 1,000 donors”. He points to the importance of organizational resources in determining manageable caseloads, describing how technology can play a vital role in optimizing donor stewardship.

Post-pandemic donor engagement strategies get the duo’s attention too. Tony advocates for quarterly in-person meetings with major donors, stressing that nothing replaces face-to-face interactions in fostering authentic relationships. He highlights creative and cost-effective ways to meet donors beyond formal settings, reinforcing the idea that ‘real’ engagement is about connection rather than transaction.

Finally, their chat turns to wealth screening tools—a topic that often gets mixed reactions from fundraising professionals. Tony offers a pragmatic view: while such tools provide valuable donor insights and improve targeted messaging, they should be evaluated based on an NPO’s revenue structure and fundraising strategy. For orgs heavily reliant on special events, wealth screening may not be a priority, whereas those seeking to expand individual giving programs might find it indispensable.

Throughout this fast-paced session, Julia and Tony blend expertise with humor, making complex fundraising topics engaging fun.

#FundraisingStrategy #DonorEngagement #NonprofitLeadership

Find us Live daily on YouTube!

Find us Live daily on LinkedIn!

Find us Live daily on X: @Nonprofit_Show

Our national co-hosts and amazing guests discuss management, money and missions of nonprofits!
12:30pm ET 11:30am CT 10:30am MT 9:30am PT

Send us your ideas for Show Guests or Topics: [e-mail]
Visit us on the web:The Nonprofit Show