Episode 72: The Murders of Cheryl Baker and Nadja and Peyton Medley: When Dreams Dissolve into Nightmare The Idaho Family Tragedy

Sinners Among Saints

Send us a Text Message.

Returning from our brief hiatus, my co-host and I found ourselves reflecting on the unexpected liberty a day off can grant, only to be soberly reminded of life's fragility through the recent, harrowing event at a Provo assisted living facility. We share with you a deep dive into the critical need for enhanced safety measures in such facilities, sparked by the loss of a dementia patient who met a tragic fate in a walk-in freezer. The conversation turns personal as we recount similar experiences and the urgent necessity for vigilance in protecting the most vulnerable among us.
The episode then pivots to the poignant story of Nadja Medley, a woman whose life was a stunning mosaic of resilience and sorrow. As we honor her memory, we recount her journey from the depths of grief to the heights of single parenthood and career fulfillment, only to be cut short by incomprehensible violence. Amid these reflections, we also swap tales from a girls' trip to Vegas, painting a vivid picture of the sometimes bizarre world of massage therapy, and the critical importance of personal boundaries.
As the narrative darkens, we unravel the chilling mystery of a family's dream turned nightmare in a small Idaho town. The saga of Nadja, Mike Bollinger, and their blended family unfolds with all the twists of a crime thriller, leaving a community, law enforcement, and us, the storytellers, grappling with the weight of tragedy and the enigmatic figure at its center. Join us for this emotional ride as we piece together a story of deception, a double life, and the indelible scars left on those who survive.

Thanks for all the support!! Please follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Tik Tok, or email us, and remember we now have a Patreon!!
patreon.com/sinnersamongsaintspodcast
[e-mail]
Tik Tok @sinnersamongsaints

Розділи

1. Tragic Incident in Nursing Home (00:00:00)

2. Tragic Life Events of Nadja Medley (00:12:53)

3. Weird Massage Experiences (00:18:48)

4. Family Adventures and Financial Struggles (00:30:36)

5. Double Life Leads to Tragic Outcome (00:38:36)

6. Serial Philandering and Tragic Deception (00:49:03)

7. Mysterious Murders and Disappearance (01:01:09)

8. The Mysterious Case of Mike Bollinger (01:13:23)